This is our fourth trip to the Maldives in four years and we've stayed in other comparable prices over-water villas at other resorts. We picked Athuruga for the house reef and because our first choice was booked and the price was discounted. Got the all inclusive package. Arrival went smoothly since the new international airport recently opened and there. was NO waiting for immigration because we did the pre-arrival form online. The seaplane terminal was a different story and we waited 3 hours and the new terminal did not give free food. and drinks as in the past. The flight was over a half hour and we were dropped on a pontoon raft, from which the resort picked us up. The greeting and check-in at Diamonds Athuruga was good and our over-water villa was fantastic and had the most indoor space compared to the others we've stayed in at other resorts. The mini bar was free and there was champagne and a fruit bowl, A very thoughtful design, was that the air conditioner was down a short hallway, above the front door, and did not blow cold air over the bed. The villa was clean and the toilet was in a seperate room with a urinal, to save water, I guess. The shower was in its own room, with a lockable door, to the deck, so you could come in directly from the ocean and shower off. There was a second shower with a full stream of water to wash snorkel gear, sand or, for another person. We never ran out of hot water. The steps down into the ocean were kept clean of slippery algae. The villa was cleaned twice daily, unless you put out the "do not disturb sign" The only thing the villa did not have that the other villas we stayed in had, were underwater lights that you could turn on at night to see the fish, which are attracted to the lights. There were long sliding doors with two sets of curtains, facing the deck and you could forgo the AC at night and leave the sliders open to get the ocean breeze and sound of the wave. Five stars for the villa-it was the best and very quiet. Our main interest is snorkelling and usually 3 hours or more a day depending on weather and tides. Diamonds Athuruga had the best reef and it was close, so we didn't have to swim 20 minutes, each way to get to the drop-off. Very little current during the tide going out and we swam around the entire island in about two hours. Most of the Maldives coral were been killed some years back during a heat wave, but at Athuruga, it was all growing back and in relatively good shape compared to the other places we stayed. We saw the usual critters, lots of reef sharks, only one turtle, lion fish, morays, rays, and lots of fish. Another thing we were happy about, was that Athuruga allowed night snorkelling, which most place do not. At night we were disappointed because we did not see any octopus or lobsters, but saw a humongous shark, crabs, nudibranchs, and a sea snake. Only went once at night in the four nights we were there. We both have 3mm wetsuits, gloves, booties, and two underwater lights each. If you want to snorkel for hours, the wetsuit is a must as you will otherwise get cold, and I tried my 1.5 mm wetsuit but got cold after an hour or so. The water was clean with no trash. Five stars for the reef! Lastly, our big disappointment was the food. The quality, amount, and variety of the food sucked! Okay, we understand that August brings lots of Italians, and I'd guess that three quarters of the guests were Italian on some kind of cheap vacation bought through a travel agent. I don't expect the same, pizza and pastas, every. lunch and dinner. The was a barbecue with a few types of fresh fish and sometimes beef or pork chops, but the wait was over 20 minutes and they ran out of pork chops, the night they had them, and out of beef another night. No Chinese, Japanese, Greek, Thai, and very little Indian. I missed the dosas at breakfast. No shrimp, roast beef, lamb, burgers, prime rib, or anything that was more expensive. Who makes potato lasagne with mashed potatoes instead of ricotta? Eggplant parmesan was a mishmash of chopped eggplant and veggies with a little parmesan cheese on top. I actually gained a kilo I four days because there wasn't enough meat or fish to fill up on and I had sub par pizza every meal. The coffee was excellent, as you would expect at a resort that caters to Italians and even some of the wait staff spoke Italian. The food was one star and why we will not go back. The outside restaurant on the all inclusive was better, but the menu didn't change and the portions were small. Was staff were prompt and friendly. Food was one star!