I never write these but I was compelled after being so shocked when our experience was mediocre at best. My guess is that people are impressed by the chocolate, and overall don’t have much of a palette. The setting is within the hotel, I would say other patrons are guests at the hotel. Very casual attire. Decor very casual, I thought. We started with breads and 3 dipping sauces which was nice. The chocolate ones were literally just a mild chocolate added to butter, and balsamic. Didn’t really have any unique flavor. The pesto was my favorite thing we ate the whole night. I ordered the shrimp cocktail which had no flavor of its own, and was smothered in mayonnaise sauce. It was also 2 pcs of medium Shrimp. We then had the mahi mahi which I kid you not, must have been steamed without salt or any preparations. It had no flavor other than fish. The tiny side of vegetables was mushy and again lacked flavor, even salt. I found the service to be subpar - we had to ask for an ice bucket for our wine. The waiters came by every 5 mins or so to clear something off our plate when we were not done. There were plenty of other seats and it wasn’t closing time so their pushiness was off putting. Oddly, I had to contact a different waiter for a glass of ice and to order a drink. They were out of the one cocktail I chose, so I got an espresso martini (the best on the island). It wasn’t terrible but def not the best on the island. The chocolate mousse dessert was delicious, no complaints. We also ordered something that was like a flambé mountain. It was literally flavorless merengue lit on fire with no instructions and a few bland sauces. I must have blew out my flame too soon bc it mostly tasted like grain alcohol and a sauce that lacked flavor. What an odd choice for a desert. The downstairs pool area looked like it would be a vibe during the day. We were honestly gobsmacked that this got such rave reviews. It was our least favorite on the island. Maybe a good value if you are all inclusive but not worth the $270ish we paid for 1 entree, 2 apps, - few drinks and dessert.